Michael stood by the fresh grave, unable to bring himself to leave. Nearby, the car waited, where his wife, Paula, sat shivering, her eyes red and swollen from days of weeping.
But it wasn't for himself or his wife that he felt the sharpest sting of pity now. The most precious person in his life was gone. Two days ago, they had brought home the body of their younger son, Ethan, who had only just moved to the city this past fall to start university.
For three days, Michael and his eldest son, David, had racked their brains trying to understand how this could have happened. Why would a young, brilliant, popular kid take his own life? What could have possibly driven him to step out of an eighth-story window? Ethan knew there would be no surviving that fall. He had consciously stepped toward oblivion—leaving a life of love and comfort for the darkness and silence of a grave.
***
Interviews with friends, acquaintances, and classmates had yielded nothing. Everyone said the same thing: his behavior hadn't changed at all recently. Just as he had been six months ago, he was cheerful and outgoing. He was dating a girl from his classes named Christina.
There had been no major fights, not even a minor disagreement between them. School came easily to the former high school valedictorian, and he never wanted for money.
The only troubling thing Christina could recall was a single incident. One night, Ethan had woken up drenched in sweat and tears. He told her he'd had a nightmare about a woman dressed in mourning clothes, leading a small boy by the hand. When the pair reached him, the woman placed the child's hand in his. The moment he touched the small palm, Ethan realized it was ice-cold. He tried to let go, but the small hand clung to his with a grip he couldn't break. The terror had sent him into hysterics until he finally woke up.
Investigators found no other red flags in the boy's life. There was no apparent motive for suicide. In fact, his mother had spoken to him on his cell phone just an hour before the police called. He had been telling her about his plans for the evening. There was no hint of sadness, confusion, or indifference. Just an ordinary conversation—one of hundreds they'd had since he moved away.
***
Michael and Paula had raised two boys to adulthood and felt certain of their future success. David had married a year ago and moved out of their small city apartment into a new suburban house his parents had helped buy. The apartment had then gone to Ethan, along with an old sedan. It was a setup for a happy, successful life. Instead, it had ended in tragedy.
Michael had always imagined that crows should circle a cemetery—birds of grief, ruin, and death. But there wasn't a crow in sight. A few hundred yards away, the pine forest stood green and vibrant, and a pale winter sun peeked through the gray clouds. If it weren't for the headstones surrounding him, Michael might have felt a sense of peace. Clear days were rare in winter, and he and his wife had learned to appreciate even the smallest gifts of fate.
The toxicology report showed psychotropic substances in the boy's blood. Apparently, he had needed "help" to take that final step over the edge. Upon learning this, Michael suppressed a sigh of relief. At least his son hadn't been in his right mind when he killed himself. The family immediately decided to keep this a secret. Their town was small, and there were plenty of envious, small-minded people.
Rumors would start instantly about "big city drug habits," about the decadence that money brings, and about "careless parents" who gave their sons too much freedom and cash. None of it was true. Ethan always told his mother what he was spending and where. Michael's busy schedule lately had meant leaving most of the supervision to Paula.
Before that, from the day he was born until high school graduation, Michael had taken the lead in the boy's upbringing. Their second child had occupied the center of Michael's heart from the moment he arrived. First steps, school, graduation—eighteen years had flown by in a blur of business and family. One never hindered the other, even early in his career. Ethan had received every bit of his father's love and attention.
Theory says a parent's love for their children should be equal, but practice often tells a different story. The youngest are often loved more fiercely, protected more deeply, and punished more gently. That was the case for Michael and Paula. Perhaps it was because of the boy's health; until he was six, he had been under constant medical supervision for a suspected heart defect.
They had taken him to every major cardiology center in the country. He had been listened to with stethoscopes, studied with EKGs, and examined by every available method. The fears turned out to be unfounded. As he grew, the medical treatments worked; his heart strengthened, and he hit a growth spurt. But the love, intensified by the early fear of loss, never faded.
***
Staring at the mound of earth hidden beneath a pile of funeral wreaths, Michael began to sift through his life, looking for the cause of this tragedy. What was his son paying for? What sin lay at the root of this all-consuming grief? Why, instead of a seat on the bus that always brought Ethan home, did the boy now occupy a plot of land in the town cemetery?
Like any young man, Michael had started life feeling like the master of the world. He had stepped on a few toes, fired unreliable employees, and been ruthless with laziness. He'd had to pay a hefty "consultation fee" to some local officials to get his pharmacies opened. But he didn't feel he had any great sins on his conscience. Thank God the cutthroat nature of the business world in the nineties hadn't turned violent in their remote town. His competitors were alive and well; he'd even befriended some over the years.
Only one incident troubled his soul. It was summer, just before his senior year of high school. A group of classmates, including Michael, had picked up some girls after a dance and driven out to the lake. As usual, they brought drinks and snacks.
The girls had hesitated at first but soon joined the fun. The next morning, Michael woke up lying next to a girl named Sarah.
He had never even liked her. He didn't know what had possessed him; likely the alcohol stirring his baser instincts. Looking around, Michael found his jeans hanging from a tree. He dressed quickly and slipped away from the clearing before Sarah woke up. For several days, he intended to go to her and explain himself, but he never found the courage. Over the next two months of summer, his conscience went quiet.
The boys continued to have their fun, driving to neighboring towns for parties. On one of those trips, Michael met Paula and was instantly smitten. The love was immediate, mutual, and serious. There was no need for a long pursuit; she didn't hide that she was ready to give him her heart and soul. By the end of senior year, their parents were already discussing marriage.
It was a modest wedding, a typical student affair. Their dorms were close, and they saw each other every day. Even then, Paula was responsible about their future and was on birth control. Because of this, they graduated successfully and returned to their hometown. Michael heard little about Sarah, and he wasn't interested. They hadn't even been in the same classes for their final year. Word was she had moved to live with relatives in another city to finish school and take prep courses.
To be honest, Michael had breathed a sigh of relief back then. Though rare, the memory of that summer night would occasionally surface. Just a boy at the time, he couldn't imagine looking her in the eye on the first day of school. He didn't know what he would say or how he would act. The flush of shame would heat his face at the mere thought. But fate had spared him. Sarah had left, and he was grateful.
***
Equipped with their city degrees and experience, Michael and Paula started their business in their hometown. They opened one store, then a second. They borrowed from friends and acquaintances to expand, paying them back and borrowing again. Eventually, the outlets began to turn a profit.
Their life was happy in every way. Michael truly loved and valued his wife, and she felt the same. Only a few times in thirty years of marriage did he wake up in a cold sweat, fearing for his family. He would dream of that summer night. A full moon would be shining, his heart pounding in his ears. In the dream, he knew he wasn't kissing Paula, but he couldn't stop. He would only bury his face deeper into hair that smelled of a light, delicate perfume.
The birth of their firstborn, David, found the family in an old house, but a large apartment was already waiting for them nearby. They just had to finish the bathroom tiles and install a new front door. It was while picking up supplies for that door that Michael ran into Sarah at the hardware store. She was wearing a black headscarf, her face stained with tears. Michael assumed she had lost a parent.
He couldn't just walk past. The former classmates spoke:
"Hi, Sarah. Did you lose someone?"
"Hello, Michael. Yes. I lost my son a week ago."
"I am so sorry. I didn't even know you were married. But it's good you have a loving husband by your side in such a difficult time."
"Right..." Sarah said, wiping a tear from her nose before walking away.
The chance encounter unsettled Michael. He asked around and learned that Sarah had indeed been the mother of a wonderful little boy. He was seven when he died of brain cancer. A late diagnosis and the rapid progression of the disease had ended his life quickly. The mother's grief was boundless. People said she only went home from the cemetery to sleep.
At the time, Michael felt pity for Sarah. The thought that it could have been his child never entered his mind. In his view, one night couldn't result in a pregnancy. And even if it had, surely she would have told him. He managed to convince himself of this quickly and for a long time. The move and the demands of business soon swept him back into a whirlwind that left no room for idle thoughts.
***
Having cataloged every possible sin, Michael—aged ten years by this tragedy—stopped at the thought of Sarah. Suddenly, his heart clenched with a realization that had been simmering beneath the surface for a long time: he was the father of that boy who died.
Forcing himself to leave the grave that now felt so familiar, Michael decided to find the woman who had given him her innocence all those years ago. He had to ask: were her curses the reason for the death of his other son?
Sarah's mother still lived in the same apartment. Very little changed in this town. People grew into the walls of their homes, working the same jobs for decades. After getting Sarah's address from her mother, Michael drove to see her instead of attending the funeral lunch at the downtown café. His nerves made it hard to drive; despite the cold, sweat soaked into his silk tie. Within two hours, he reached the address.
The door opened almost immediately. It was as if she had been standing there, waiting for the bell. Grief had aged her, but it hadn't stolen her beauty. In her features, Michael could see the girl he had kissed so passionately on that intoxicating summer night—the girl he had forgotten as quickly as she had left town.
A heavy, halting dialogue began between two parents who had both known loss.
Sarah spoke first:
"I was expecting you, Michael. My mother told me what happened to your son. I didn't expect you today, though—not on the day of the funeral."
"I didn't expect to be here either," Michael replied. "But I couldn't go on without knowing. The guilt has been crushing me. Was that my son who died twenty-five years ago?"
Sarah looked at him with eyes full of tears before turning her gaze toward the curtains. She took a few breaths to steady herself. Her hands, resting on her lap, shook slightly. When she spoke again, her voice was thick with regret.
"Yes. You guessed right. Steven was my most precious, beloved son, and he was yours. After that night, I was ashamed—until I found out I was pregnant. Then, the role of a single mother took over. I wanted to have a child with the man I loved. I knew how indifferent you were toward me, so I didn't harbor any false hopes of marriage. I just wanted to give my whole heart to the baby.
"I decided never to tell you about Steven. Moving away made it easy. No one knew who the father was. The birth went perfectly, and we lived as a happy little family. Then that cursed illness and the loss... it clouded my mind. I started praying for God to punish you. I asked Him to take away the thing you loved most, the thing without which your life would be hell. It took all these years for my prayers to be answered..."
"But what does this have to do with me?" Michael asked. "How am I to blame, and why am I paying for your grief, Sarah?"
"You're right," she said softly. "The first year after my son died, I wasn't myself. I did a lot of terrible things. I prayed for things I shouldn't have even thought about. I realize that now, and I'm so sorry. Of course, back then, I heard you'd had a child. It felt like you and your wife had stolen my happiness. For all the years after, I tried to take those prayers back, but it didn't help. I'm so sorry, Michael. Forgive me for being a fool."
Enraged, Michael ran out to the landing without his coat. He jumped into his car and drove back home—to his wife, his other son, his daughter-in-law, and his own life. As the anger receded, it was replaced by tears of despair. He couldn't change anything now. He was seeing the consequences of things he had heard about but never believed: a mother's prayers always reach the ears of the Almighty.
Somewhere deep inside, Michael acknowledged his own guilt. He should have met with her before she left; they should have talked. He shouldn't have left her so coldly; he should have tried to end things with kindness. But what's done cannot be undone. His son had paid in full for the mistake of his father's youth.
0 comments